A big march, a borrowed number
The march itself is not in dispute. On Saturday, November 14, thousands of people walked down the Royal Mile to the Scottish Parliament, in a demonstration backed, according to Press Association reporting, by more than 80 organizations: climate groups, trade unions, tenants' groups and local campaigns fighting individual sites. Organizer material published before the march put the backing at 75+ groups. The demand was procedural, not technical: pause the projects, and let the public be consulted before any are approved.
The headline number attached to the day is softer. The 6,000 attendance figure came from Kim Pratt, a senior campaigner at Friends of the Earth Scotland, who told the Press Association she had been told an estimated 6,000 people had turned up. No police estimate appeared in the PA report. That does not make the number wrong. It makes it a campaigner's second-hand estimate, and it should be labeled that way wherever it travels.
Three totals for one pipeline
The projects the march opposed come with the same problem at larger scale. APRS, one of the groups behind the march, submitted written evidence to Holyrood's Climate Action Committee in October. Its map counts 23 hyperscale proposals in planning or pre-planning, each between 125 and 1,000 MW, totaling 7.3 GW of demand. Set against NESO's figure for Scotland's peak winter demand, just over 4 GW: the proposed 7.3 GW is about 1.8 times that peak, and adding it in full would produce roughly 2.8 times current peak demand — an illustrative calculation, not a forecast.
The grid queue tells a different total, because it counts a different set. Matt Magill of NESO told a Holyrood committee there was 9.7 GW of data centre demand in the queue; NESO press officers later corrected that figure to 8.9 GW. STV's coverage of the march, citing NESO's September figures, put the queue at 28 proposals and 8.9 GW. A queue entry is a request for a connection, not a planning approval and not a commitment to build. The two inventories — planning proposals and grid requests — are different sets, and their totals are not competing estimates of one pipeline.
A third version circulated with the march coverage itself, in Nakoda's account of BBC reporting: the same 23 proposals described as adding 9.1 GW, against a Scottish peak of about 5 GW. That pairing could not be reconciled with APRS's own committee evidence (23 projects, 7.3 GW) or NESO's peak figure (just over 4 GW) from the sources reviewed, and the basis for the 9.1 GW figure is not stated in the account.
What is actually being decided
Almost none of this pipeline exists yet. APRS estimated Scotland's operating data center capacity at 10–30 MW in 2024, and its own count found 39.6 MW across publicly listed sites over 1 MW — not necessarily a complete inventory. On any version, the contested total dwarfs what is running today. How much of a connection queue survives is a separate question: queue reforms are expected to remove speculative applications, a point made in evidence to Holyrood, and APRS's evidence notes that developers, not the named US technology companies, front most of the Scottish applications.
The immediate decision is narrower than the march's framing and more concrete. The Scottish Government says it will publish new planning guidance on data centers before the end of the year, and the Climate Action Committee's call for evidence on hyperscale sites closes November 15, 2026. The government says guidance is due before year-end; its content and application to pending proposals remain to be seen. The campaigners' core complaint — that those terms are being written after the applications arrived — is theirs to make, and it does not depend on which total turns out to be right.
Sources
- [1] Press Association reporting of the November 14 march (attendance estimate, coalition, demands), via Radio News Hub, November 14, 2026Read source
- [2] Action to Protect Rural Scotland, evidence submitted to the Climate Action Committee, October 2026 (23 proposals, 7.3 GW, NESO 9.7 GW corrected to 8.9 GW, peak demand, operating capacity)Read source
- [3] STV News coverage of the march via Europe Says (NESO September figures: 28 proposals, 8.9 GW; government spokesperson on guidance), published November 15, 2026Read source
- [4] BBC Scotland reporting via Nakoda News summary (campaign figure of 9.1 GW against a peak of about 5 GW; Chapelcross 1,000 MW), November 14–15, 2026Read source
- [5] Data Centre Review, "Scottish Parliament opens inquiry into hyperscale data centers" (inquiry scope; call for evidence closing November 15, 2026), October 8, 2026Read source
- [6] The NEN (North Edinburgh News), march report and pre-march organizer material (75+ backing organizations), November 14–15, 2026Read source