The improvement is real

Start with what got better, because it did. Until now, Gemini tied two different decisions to one switch. Keep Activity decided whether your chats were saved and whether Google could use them to train its generative AI models. Turning training off meant giving up your history. Plenty of users wanted the first without the second; enjoy.dev's account of the change notes a widely shared complaint in early November making exactly that point, including for paying subscribers.

The new structure separates the two. History controls whether chats appear in your saved history. A second setting, covering chat content including text and uploads, controls training. Leave History on, leave the training box unchecked, and you keep a record of your conversations without feeding them into model training. For users who had Keep Activity off, both new settings will be off by default. For users who had it on, history stays on and the training choice becomes theirs to make separately.

That is a cleaner design.

The other number in the update

The same update changes how long Google holds the chats of the people who turn history off. Under the previous Privacy Hub, chats made with Keep Activity off, and temporary chats, were retained with the account for 72 hours. Under the updated hub, both are kept for around two months. On the arithmetic of about 60 days against three, that is roughly a twentyfold increase — the figure The Register calculated.

Two months is also longer than the comparison points in the same market. TechCrunch notes that OpenAI says ChatGPT temporary chats may be kept for up to 30 days, and Anthropic retains Claude incognito chats for 30 days by default — both with longer-retention exceptions of their own. Google's history-off window is now about double both published figures, for the chats users most clearly signaled they did not want kept.

Google gave general reasons for retaining chats: to respond to users, process feedback, and protect Google, its users and the public, with the updated Privacy Hub adding that they stay available in case of a potential system failure. Google did not answer TechCrunch's specific questions about what prompted the increase, or whether it affects how the retained conversations are accessed or reviewed. Nothing published so far explains why the job needs two months when it previously needed three days.

What "off" still leaves behind

Three details decide what the new settings are worth in practice. The first two come from reports of Google's updated pages (enjoy.dev and TokenStrom, both November 17).

First, the training opt-out has a feedback exception. Per those reports, if History is off and you submit feedback on a response, Google collects the last 24 hours of the related chats, including attachments and data from connected apps, and reviewed feedback can be kept far longer than two months. Submitting feedback is, in effect, a documented exception to the retention the setting describes.

Second, retention and visibility are different things. A chat that never appears in your History is still retained with your account for the two-month window. Deleting what you can see does not shorten the retention period Google describes for future history-off chats.

Third, some older rules did not move. Per the same reports, Google's pages still say a subset of chats is reviewed by human reviewers, and reviewed chats can be kept, disconnected from the account, for up to three years, including after deletion. The reports of the updated hub describe no separate retention rule for subscribers.

None of this makes the new settings worthless. The training opt-out is a genuine gain, and it costs nothing to use. But the strictest privacy posture Gemini offers now comes with a longer retention window attached: around two months of your chats held after you chose not to save them, where the previous window was three days.

Sources

  1. [1] TechCrunch, "Google to keep Gemini chats for 2 months, up from 72 hours, even with history off," November 17, 2026 (read first-hand in full by ALFW)Read source
  2. [2] Google, announcement of the new Gemini settings (November 16, 2026) and Gemini Apps Privacy Hub / Gemini history help pages as updated November 16, 2026 — quoted and linked from the reports below; the retention wording "around two months" is from Google's updated pages (label only — no direct URL recorded)
  3. [3] enjoy.dev, "Gemini separates History from AI training. How to keep your chats and stop training," November 17, 2026Read source
  4. [4] TokenStrom, "'Training off' doesn't mean deleted: what eight AI services keep anyway," November 17, 2026Read source
  5. [5] Digital Trends, "Gemini users can finally save their AI chats without letting Google use them for training, but there's a catch," November 17, 2026Read source